COUNTRYSIDE · ENERGY · ACCOUNTABILITYSign the petition ↗
Protecting our countryside. Asking the difficult questions.

HOPE · Energy & countryside

MILIBAND’S £300 ENERGY PROMISE MEETS AN £881 BILL INCREASE

Hope to Save Our Countryside petition flyer reading Let’s Hold Them to Account, featuring Ed Miliband, the call to show the evidence, and petition 780321 QR code.

Labour promised Britain cheaper energy. Two years later, household bills are heading in the opposite direction. And the true scale of the increase becomes clear when we stop changing the amount of energy used in the comparison.

On 4 July 2024, when Labour won the general election, the energy price cap for a typical household was £1,568 a year.

Today, purchasing exactly the same amount of gas and electricity costs approximately £1,936 a year.

From January 2027, the latest forecast suggests that figure could reach nearly £2,450.

That is £881 more than when Labour came to power. A 56% increase.

And this is not speculation about how much energy people might consume in future. It is a comparison using the same annual consumption throughout.

FROM £300 CHEAPER TO £881 MORE EXPENSIVE

During the 2024 general election, Labour promised that its clean energy programme would save households up to £300 a year by 2030.

The message was unmistakable. Britain’s energy future would be cleaner, more secure and cheaper.

Yet on 18 November 2026, Cornwall Insight forecast that the energy price cap would rise by another 26% in January, reaching £2,166 on Ofgem’s new, lower consumption benchmark.

Apply those forecast rates to the consumption benchmark used when Labour was elected, and the figure becomes approximately £2,449.

Even before the election, in April to June 2024, the annualised cap was £1,690. By April 2025 it had risen to £1,849. It then fluctuated, reaching £1,758 in January 2026 and falling to £1,641 in April, before climbing again.

By July 2026, the same original household consumption cost approximately £1,863. By October, it was £1,936.

Now January threatens another substantial increase.

The £300 promise was for 2030, so its final outcome cannot yet be judged. But it faces an increasingly uncomfortable question: what credible evidence shows that bills will fall so dramatically from their present trajectory?

THE CHANGE TO ‘TYPICAL’ HOUSEHOLD CONSUMPTION

Here is something every household should understand.

Until July 2026, Ofgem’s typical household comparison used 2,700 kilowatt-hours of electricity and 11,500 kilowatt-hours of gas annually.

From July, Ofgem reduced those figures to 2,500 and 9,500 respectively, reflecting lower measured household consumption.

That may be a legitimate statistical update. But it does not mean purchasing the original amount of energy suddenly became cheaper.

In October 2026, the advertised annual figure was £1,723. Keep consumption at the old benchmark, however, and the cost is approximately £1,936.

That is more than £200 of difference in the headline simply because the assumed household is using less energy.

The January forecast widens that gap to approximately £283.

For a proper comparison of energy costs over time, consumption must remain constant. Otherwise, lower consumption can conceal higher prices.

A family heating the same home to the same temperature does not experience a saving merely because the statistical definition of a typical household has changed.

THE WORLD ENERGY SHOCK IS REAL. SO IS THE QUESTION OF BRITAIN’S EXPOSURE.

The latest January increase is primarily being driven by volatile wholesale gas markets and disruption associated with the conflict in the Middle East.

That matters. It would be wrong to attribute the entire increase to Miliband’s energy policies.

But it would be equally wrong to ignore the wider question of what Britain’s energy strategy is actually delivering.

The Government is committed to an enormous transformation of electricity generation, transmission networks, storage and supporting infrastructure. The financial consequences will extend well beyond the construction of wind turbines and solar farms.

Networks must be reinforced. Substations must be expanded. New generation must be connected. Electricity must still be available when wind and solar output falls.

Those investments have costs, and Ofgem has already confirmed additional network-cost pressures under the RIIO-3 price-control framework.

The Government argues that greater reliance on domestic low-carbon electricity will eventually reduce exposure to international gas prices. That is a serious argument which deserves to be tested.

But the benefits must be demonstrated against the complete costs of the system, not simply the projected cost of generating individual units of renewable electricity.

Cheap generation is not the same thing as cheap electricity delivered reliably to households.

EVEN GOVERNMENT SUPPORT CANNOT ERASE THE INCREASE

The Government has introduced measures intended to ease bills.

Around £150 of environmental and social scheme costs was removed from the average household bill from April 2026 through changes to funding. VAT on domestic electricity has been temporarily abolished, and the October 2026 Budget announced a separate £100 Household Energy Payment for eligible households in England.

These measures offer genuine bill relief, although transferring expenditure into taxation does not necessarily eliminate the underlying cost to the public.

Crucially, Cornwall Insight’s January forecast already incorporates the temporary electricity VAT reduction.

The separate £100 payment is not deducted from its price-cap forecast.

And despite these interventions, the forecast still points towards a substantial increase.

THE £300 PROMISE NEEDS A FULL FINANCIAL ACCOUNTING

There was a fundamental weakness in the original £300 claim.

Full Fact established in June 2024 that the underlying estimate came from earlier research into household electricity costs, rather than a direct calculation of Labour’s particular policy programme. Its baseline was already out of date before the election.

Now, more than two years later, the question has become more urgent.

What will it cost to deliver the electricity system envisaged for 2030? What additional transmission infrastructure is needed? How much will financing, backup generation, balancing, storage, network reinforcement and eventual asset replacement cost?

Which costs will appear on household bills, which will be funded through taxation, and which will be passed on through the prices of goods and services?

And, above all, where is the independently verified calculation proving that the complete programme will leave households £300 better off?

That is the evidence Parliament and the British public deserve to see.

MAKE THEM SHOW THE EVIDENCE

This is why our parliamentary petition calls for an independent national assessment of the full financial, economic, environmental and infrastructure consequences of the Climate Change Act targets before the country proceeds further under those statutory obligations.

Households should not be expected to accept promises of future savings without being shown how those savings will actually be delivered.

Industry needs competitive energy. Families need affordable heating. Britain needs dependable power. And our countryside deserves proper protection from unnecessary development.

The comparison is now stark.

£1,568 when Labour took office. Approximately £1,936 today. Nearly £2,450 forecast for January 2027.

Same household. Same consumption. Different prices.

Miliband’s £300 promise remains a commitment for 2030. But each increase places a greater burden on the Government to demonstrate that it is achievable.

The public deserves more than another promise. It deserves the complete accounts.

MAKE THEM SHOW THE EVIDENCE.

Sign and share the parliamentary petition: https://petition.parliament.uk/petitions/780321

Shane Oxer — Campaigner for fairer and affordable energy


Evidence note

The comparison holds annual household consumption constant at 2,700 kWh electricity and 11,500 kWh gas, using national-average Direct Debit price-cap unit rates and standing charges. Figures are annualised illustrations, not cumulative expenditure or a guarantee of actual household bills. January 2027 remains a forecast pending Ofgem’s announcement on 25 November 2026. The estimated £2,449 uses Cornwall Insight’s published forecast and adds the cost of the additional consumption at its forecast unit rates.

Sources: Ofgem July 2024, Ofgem October 2026 rates, Cornwall Insight, 18 November 2026, Full Fact’s examination of the £300 promise, and Budget 2026.