HOPE TO SAVE OUR COUNTRYSIDE | 20 November 2026
1,277 recorded objections. A unanimous rejection by elected councillors. Green Belt in law and green in reality — but reclassified as Grey Belt on paper. Now the agricultural-land defence has also been dropped. Who is standing up for Marr?

Look at these photographs. This is not an abandoned industrial site waiting to be rescued. It is open, cultivated countryside, edged by hedgerows and mature trees, with rural homes, businesses and the setting of Marr village close by.
Yet this is the landscape Enviromena wants to cover with a solar development of around 77 hectares for up to 40 years. Rows of panels, perimeter fencing, access tracks and electrical equipment would fundamentally change the way these fields are seen and used.
The site is Green Belt in law and green in reality. “Grey Belt” is a planning classification, not an accurate description of these photographs and certainly not a grant of planning permission.
What demands scrutiny is how Doncaster Council’s own case against this development has progressively narrowed since elected councillors refused the scheme.
Residents objected. Councillors refused. Officers wanted approval.
Doncaster’s December 2025 committee report recorded 1,277 objections in the first consultation round, including a petition, with additional objections later. These were not abstract internet signatures. They concerned productive farmland, rural character, local businesses, rights of way and the future of a real community.
Planning officers nevertheless recommended approval. On 16 December 2025, the elected Planning Committee unanimously rejected that recommendation. Formal refusal followed on 19 December.
That was a proper exercise of local democratic responsibility. Committee members did not have to accept the officers’ assessment of the planning balance. They examined the evidence and reached a different conclusion.
The refusal had three substantial grounds: harm to the Green Belt; unacceptable landscape and visual impact, including Marr Conservation Area and Marr Grange Farm Shop and Tea Rooms; and the significant loss of best and most versatile agricultural land for 40 years.



GREEN BELT IN LAW. GREEN IN REALITY. “GREY” ON PAPER.
Study these photographs. The hedgerows are real. The arable fields are real. So are the trees, surrounding farmland, rural businesses and open views. This is not a derelict industrial estate waiting for a new purpose. This is countryside being used.
Under planning law, Grey Belt is still land within the Green Belt. The label applies when specific policy tests are met. It does not mean the grass has gone grey, the fields have stopped producing crops or that the land has ceased to serve its community. The bitter visual irony is that the land would look more like a built electricity installation after the arrays and fencing arrived.
The Government’s own Green Belt guidance says identifying Grey Belt land does not automatically mean development should be approved. It also recognises that openness has visual as well as spatial dimensions and that the duration of development matters. Forty years matters. The views matter. The farming matters.
Now look at paragraph 24 of Doncaster’s 10 March 2026 officer report. It states that the proposed scheme would “not represent encroachment into the countryside” for the relevant Green Belt purpose. This is a technical planning conclusion, not a claim that the landscape is already built over. But it needs to be explained: what evidence justified that conclusion for roughly 77 hectares of open agricultural land?
The same report says the land should now qualify as Grey Belt after the High Court’s Wrotham judgment clarified the test. The judgment mattered and officers were right to take the law into account. But the judgment did not order that solar panels be installed at Marr, nor did it erase the separate landscape and agricultural impacts.
Photographs cannot determine the legal Grey Belt classification by themselves. Equally, an officer’s classification cannot make the change to the physical landscape vanish. Residents deserve published before-and-after views from matching viewpoints, a full explanation of the policy judgment and a serious account of the site’s countryside character.
Call it Grey Belt on a planning document if the statutory tests require it. Do not pretend that makes this countryside any less green, any less cultivated, or any less deserving of scrutiny.
First the Green Belt defence went
In March 2026, officers returned to committee following the High Court’s Wrotham judgment on Grey Belt policy. They advised that continuing the Green Belt refusal ground would be legally difficult and expose the council to costs. On 10 March, councillors endorsed its withdrawal by five votes to none, with two abstentions.
The judgment was a real legal development. It would be wrong to pretend officers had no legal reason to revisit their case. But it is equally wrong to pretend that a revised policy assessment makes this productive countryside a brownfield wasteland. Grey Belt is not the same as previously developed land.
And in March, the council explicitly told councillors that the two remaining refusal grounds — landscape and agricultural land — were defensible. That assurance deserves to be set alongside the later officer-level decision to withdraw the farmland defence.
The fields did not change. Their agricultural use did not change. The views did not change. The impact of rows of panels, fencing, associated equipment and access works did not vanish because the planning terminology changed.
Crucially, in March the council told the committee that its other two refusal grounds — landscape and agricultural land — remained defensible.
Then came the farmland retreat — decided before the public was told
On 12 November 2026, the Service Director for Development and Traded Services decided that Doncaster Council would no longer defend the BMV agricultural-land refusal ground at the appeal inquiry. The decision was published on 18 November, the day after the inquiry opened.
The published decision cites written advice from counsel. It says it would be unreasonable to maintain the objection in light of a sheep-grazing condition offered by the developer, because the council could face an adverse award of appeal costs.
Think about what this means. In March, elected members had been told the agricultural-land objection was defensible. In November, an officer-level decision removed it from the council’s appeal case. The public decision record labels the action not a key decision and not subject to call-in.
Why was this not brought back for a public decision by the same elected committee? When did councillors first receive the legal advice? When were objectors and the local community informed? Why was the decision made on 12 November but published only after the inquiry had started?
These are not personal accusations against individual officers. They are basic questions about democratic accountability and the transparency of a planning appeal.
On the same 12 November date, the Service Director also authorised completing a Section 106 agreement addressing ecological benefits and monitoring if the proposal proceeds. That is a normal protective legal step in an appeal, not evidence that permission has already been given. But taken with the farmland decision, it makes a full explanation of the council’s appeal strategy all the more important.
Since when did sheep grazing equal arable farming?
The original committee’s agricultural objection was not just about whether a few animals might survive beneath panels. It was about removing a significant area of productive agricultural land from normal arable use for four decades.
Sheep grazing may be possible beneath some solar arrays. But a proposed grazing condition does not, by itself, demonstrate that the existing ability to produce crops such as wheat, barley or potatoes would be retained. Nor does it answer what proportion of the land would actually be grazed, how that would be monitored, who would enforce it, or what happens if the grazing never takes place.
The public deserves the actual condition, the supporting agricultural evidence, a credible grazing-management plan and a clear explanation of why this was considered sufficient to abandon a formal refusal ground.
The photographs show fields in cultivation. They do not establish the precise agricultural land grade — that requires the relevant soil surveys and classification evidence. That is why the BMV evidence should be examined rather than waved away with an assurance about sheep.
Forty years is a generation of lost choices. Calling the development “temporary” does not make those decades disappear.

And what about the grid connection?
For a project advertised as an answer to Britain’s energy needs, one would expect its grid connection and associated environmental consequences to be examined with equal rigour.
Objectors have raised an approximately six-kilometre underground cable corridor. The council’s own application register confirms a separate screening request, 26/01114/SCRE, submitted in June 2026 to consider the solar development together with the underground connection route; that screening case was decided in July.
The existence of that screening process does not prove an environmental assessment was unlawfully omitted. But it makes disclosure essential. What were the precise route alternatives? What was screened? What construction impacts were assessed cumulatively with the solar farm? What evidence establishes when the connection could actually operate?
Why did this infrastructure issue not feature among the formal reasons for refusal — and where can residents see the full explanation?
The landscape has not disappeared. These photographs are the evidence.
The surviving reason for refusal concerns landscape and visual harm, and these images help show why that matters.
Doncaster’s original planning report recorded that its landscape consultants considered the site would acquire a more developed character and that certain views would be blocked or curtailed. The formal refusal specifically referred to Marr Conservation Area, neighbouring homes, and the visual amenities of the family-run Marr Grange Farm Shop and Tea Rooms.
These are real places whose setting contributes to community life and the rural economy. A strip of new planting cannot immediately replace the open views a proposal would change, nor does landscaping automatically eliminate industrial-scale visual effects.






£6.5 million for the council. But what price for the countryside?
Before the December decision, Enviromena publicly projected more than £6.5 million in business rates directly to Doncaster Council over the scheme’s lifespan. It also promoted a £200,000 community benefit fund. These are the developer’s projections and offers, not established receipts or proof that any planning decision was influenced by money.
But the figures make one question unavoidable: what weight, if any, did financial benefits receive in the officers’ recommendation and in the council’s appeal strategy?
In March, officers’ report warned of a possible £100,000–£500,000 costs exposure if the council pursued an unreasonable defence. By November, the council cited costs risk again when withdrawing the farmland objection.
A public authority must protect taxpayers against avoidable appeal costs. It must also show that litigation risk is not allowed to become an automatic reason to surrender properly evidenced planning concerns. Residents deserve to see how those judgments were made, not simply be told they were made.
Who is meant to help the local people?
Planning officers are not paid to rubber-stamp every objection. Their duty is to give lawful, independent, evidence-based advice. But neither are elected planning committees ceremonial bodies whose decisions should be quietly hollowed out at the first sign of an appeal.
The council now needs to answer publicly: Who authorised the November change? Why was a full committee reconsideration not sought, as it was in March? What did the grazing condition actually prove? Where is the disclosed assessment of the underground cable route and its cumulative impacts? What financial benefits were included in the planning balance? And precisely how will officers now defend the landscape refusal ground at inquiry?
The independent Planning Inspector will determine the appeal, and the council is still defending landscape and visual harm. So this is not evidence that permission has already been granted, nor proof of secret collusion. It is, however, ample evidence to demand a much more transparent explanation of how the council’s defence has narrowed.
The people of Marr did their part. They read the plans, made objections, attended meetings and persuaded elected councillors to reject the proposal. They should not now be expected to watch vital parts of that refusal dissolve behind procedural language and legal-cost warnings.
Who really helps local people? The public planning service must act lawfully and independently, but it must also explain its decisions in language residents can understand. Where elected members have refused a scheme, any later narrowing of the appeal defence should be especially transparent.
These fields are not a planning abstraction. They are the landscape residents live beside and farmers work. A policy label cannot replace public accountability.
Local democracy must mean something after the committee room empties.
H.O.P.E. — Hope to Save Our Countryside — will keep asking the questions Doncaster’s residents deserve to have answered.
Shane Oxer — Campaigner for fairer and affordable energy
Evidence and public records
Figures and dates checked against records available 20 November 2026. The 1,277 figure relates to objections in the first consultation round; the £6.5 million and £200,000 figures are developer claims. The approximate six-kilometre cable length is an issue raised by objectors; the separate screening application confirms the existence of a proposed underground corridor. The BMV and Green Belt refusal grounds are no longer defended by the council; landscape and visual harm remains a defended ground.
- Doncaster Planning Committee agenda and officer report, 16 December 2025.
- Planning Committee minutes, 10 March 2026.
- Officer report on the Green Belt appeal position, March 2026.
- Delegated decision PLACE26 0132, 12 November 2026, published 18 November 2026.
- Grid-cable and solar-farm EIA screening 26/01114/SCRE.
- Planning Inspectorate appeal 6010146.
- Enviromena’s December 2025 financial-benefit claims.
- Doncaster Free Press reporting on the unanimous refusal.
- Government Green Belt guidance — Grey Belt, openness and planning decisions.
- Current National Planning Policy Framework, chapter 13.
- Doncaster’s Section 106 delegated decision, 12 November 2026.


Leave a Reply