COUNTRYSIDE · ENERGY · ACCOUNTABILITYSign the petition ↗
Protecting our countryside. Asking the difficult questions.

HOPE · Energy & countryside

THE GOVERNMENT HAS SAID NO — BUT THE FIGHT FOR THE TRUTH ABOUT NET ZERO COSTS CONTINUES

Hope to Save Our Countryside petition flyer reading Let’s Hold Them to Account, featuring Ed Miliband, the call to show the evidence, and petition 780321 QR code.

13,627 signatures. A Government refusal. A formal challenge to Parliament. And a question that still deserves an answer: What will this really cost Britain?

On 20 November 2026, the Government responded to my Parliamentary Petition 780321, calling for the temporary suspension of the Climate Change Act targets pending an independent national assessment of their full costs and consequences.

Its answer was unequivocal.

“We will not suspend the UK’s statutory carbon budgets or 2050 net zero target.”

The Department for Energy Security and Net Zero insists that the costs and impacts have already been assessed.

But after months of investigating Britain’s electricity grid, infrastructure requirements, government expenditure and energy policies, I believe a fundamental question remains unanswered.

Where is the single, independently reconciled national assessment showing what this entire transformation will physically require, what it will cost, who will pay, and whether alternative approaches have been properly compared?

That is what the petition is asking for. And that is why this campaign must continue.

THE £865 BILLION CLAIM — LOOK BEHIND THE NUMBERS

The Government’s response relies heavily on its Seventh Carbon Budget Impact Assessment.

It claims approximately £755 billion in net costs will be outweighed by £1.62 trillion in benefits, producing an estimated £865 billion positive net present value between 2025 and 2050.

Those numbers sound reassuring. But our investigation into the Government’s own published calculations raises questions that cannot simply be dismissed.

The assessment identifies approximately £880 billion in additional capital and financing costs. Reconstructing the operating-cost figures implies a further £325 billion in operating requirements before deducting approximately £445 billion in projected fossil-fuel savings.

That is roughly £1.205 trillion in modelled gross additional resource requirements before those savings are deducted.

These are discounted economic estimates against the Government’s chosen comparison scenario, not an actual spending bill or a forecast of Exchequer expenditure. But the scale matters.

Now examine the supposed £1.62 trillion in benefits. Approximately £1.495 trillion comes from monetised carbon savings.

These are economic valuations assigned to emissions reductions under the Government’s appraisal methodology. They are not £1.495 trillion in cash savings appearing in household bank accounts, public finances or business balance sheets.

Climate and environmental benefits have legitimate economic value. But those values must be distinguished from actual money spent, bills paid and investments financed.

There is another revealing finding.

Against the Government’s existing-policy baseline, the preferred carbon-budget option produces an estimated £330 billion positive net present value under central carbon valuations. Apply the Government’s own lower-carbon-value sensitivity, and that becomes an estimated £160 billion net loss.

That is a £490 billion change in the calculated outcome.

It does not prove that every Net Zero policy is uneconomic. It demonstrates how significantly the appraisal result depends on the valuation assumptions employed.

This is precisely the sort of evidence Parliament should examine.

Source: Seventh Carbon Budget Impact Assessment (May 2026), particularly Tables 6 and 8.

THE NATIONAL AUDIT OFFICE HAS ALREADY IDENTIFIED A SERIOUS PROBLEM

In September 2026, the National Audit Office published its investigation into Britain’s electricity transmission network. Its findings deserve far greater public attention.

Ofgem estimates approximately £70 billion of electricity transmission investment will be required between 2025 and 2031.

The NAO reported that grid constraint costs had reached approximately £1.9 billion in 2025/26, with potentially much higher costs by 2030 if necessary action is not taken.

More importantly, the NAO identified the absence of an integrated plan or whole-system appraisal demonstrating that the selected transmission projects represent the best way of achieving the Government’s objectives.

Think about that. The Government tells petitioners that sufficient assessments already exist.

Yet the independent public spending watchdog has identified a significant whole-system appraisal gap in one of the most expensive and essential parts of the transformation.

That does not mean the Government has undertaken no assessments. It means there is a serious distinction between individual assessments, economic modelling and an integrated national account of delivery.

That distinction is at the heart of this petition.

Source: National Audit Office, Upgrading the electricity transmission network (September 2026).

WHAT ABOUT OUR FARMLAND, COUNTRYSIDE AND ENERGY SECURITY?

For communities confronting enormous solar developments, battery installations, new substations, overhead transmission lines and industrial infrastructure, this is not merely an argument about economic models.

It is about the countryside around their homes. It is about productive farmland, peatland, landscapes and the cumulative effects of multiple developments.

It is about what happens when generation projects are approved faster than the electricity network can accommodate them.

It is also about the electricity demand that Britain may face from data centres, transport electrification, electric heating and industrial growth.

How much additional dependable generating capacity will Britain need?

How many new substations, transformers, cables, pylons and storage installations will be required?

What will the complete programme cost consumers, businesses and taxpayers?

And what happens if essential infrastructure cannot be delivered when planned?

These are practical engineering and economic questions.

The Government is right that retaining our existing energy system also has costs. Gas infrastructure, electricity networks and ageing power stations cannot simply be maintained indefinitely without investment.

But that makes a fair comparison between alternative energy pathways more important, not less.

A genuinely independent assessment should compare the whole-system costs of different approaches using consistent assumptions about demand, security of supply, infrastructure, financing and environmental impacts.

I HAVE NOW WRITTEN DIRECTLY TO THE PETITIONS COMMITTEE

On 21 November, I sent a formal letter to the Clerk of Parliament’s Petitions Committee, copying my local MP, John Healey.

I explained that the Government’s response leaves substantial questions about the full financial and physical consequences of its Net Zero programme.

Our investigation has already produced a six-page evidence-based rebuttal containing ten specific questions for the Government.

Behind that sits a 138-page parliamentary evidence dossier examining historical government decisions, regulatory warnings, grid investment, financial costs, infrastructure dependencies and official assessments.

I have asked the Committee to consider three things.

First, whether our six-page rebuttal can be formally placed before it when considering the Government’s response.

Second, whether the Committee will consider requesting further answers from DESNZ to the ten outstanding questions.

Third, how we can formally submit the complete 138-page evidence dossier for parliamentary consideration.

These are requests, not assurances that the Committee has already accepted the evidence or agreed to further scrutiny.

My intention is straightforward. I want the Government’s claims tested against the evidence, not simply repeated as the final word.

This is not a request for Parliament to ignore climate risks. It is a request to examine the consequences of the legislation, the alternatives available and the economic and physical assumptions on which national policy depends.

WHY 100,000 SIGNATURES STILL MATTERS

When this petition reached 10,000 signatures, the Government was required to respond. It has now done so. But a Government response does not end the petition.

At 100,000 signatures, it must be considered by the Petitions Committee for a parliamentary debate. Such debates are usually held, although they are not automatically guaranteed.

A debate would not itself suspend the Climate Change Act or force the Government to change its policy.

What it could do is allow MPs to challenge ministers, examine the disputed evidence and demand clearer answers on the costs, benefits, alternatives and practical delivery of these targets.

That is an important opportunity for public accountability.

Because decisions affecting Britain’s energy system, homes, industry, transport and countryside should be supported by evidence that can withstand proper scrutiny.

If the Government believes its existing assessments fully answer these questions, it should be able to demonstrate that clearly.

Our petition remains open until 21 March 2027.

There are still thousands of people who have not had an opportunity to examine what the Climate Change Act means for the country, what the Government claims it will cost and what independent scrutiny has identified.

For those who share our call for a comprehensive, independent assessment, the petition remains an opportunity to put that request before Parliament.

The Government has given its answer. I have challenged that answer through the proper parliamentary channels.

Now the next question is whether Parliament will examine the evidence in greater depth.

What will it cost? What is included? What is missing? Who pays?

Those four questions should be answerable. And they should not disappear because a department says the matter has already been assessed.

READ, SIGN OR SHARE PARLIAMENTARY PETITION 780321

Suspend Climate Change Act targets & undertake a full national impact assessment

Read the petition and Government response on the UK Parliament website

Shane Oxer — Campaigner for fairer and affordable energy
Hope to Save Our Countryside


Evidence note: Figures quoted from the May 2026 Seventh Carbon Budget Impact Assessment are modelled, discounted estimates, expressed in 2025 prices. The £1.205 trillion reconstruction is derived from the assessment’s component costs before modelled fossil-fuel savings; it is not an additional sum to be added to the published £755 billion net cost. The NAO’s £70 billion transmission figure covers a different period and scope and must not automatically be added to the carbon-budget totals. The petition signature count is the figure recorded on 21 November 2026.