Who really pays to bury carbon under the sea?
“How much will it cost to capture just one tonne of CO₂, pipe it across the countryside and store it under the seabed?”
“How much will the cement and lime companies pay themselves — and how much could come out of our taxes, household bills or the prices we pay?”
“And if this huge scheme costs more than promised, or captures less carbon than expected, who picks up the bill?”
Those three questions should be answered before Peak Cluster is allowed to commit communities and farmland to decades of new industrial infrastructure. At present, there is no published, final breakdown showing what every tonne actually captured and permanently stored would cost, what industrial customers would pay commercially, and what share might ultimately fall on the public.
Peak Cluster proposes to capture CO₂ from cement and lime works, compress and transport it through approximately 200 kilometres of new onshore pipeline, and send it to offshore geological storage beneath the East Irish Sea. It says it aims to prevent more than three million tonnes of CO₂ entering the atmosphere annually. That is a forecast, not a measured operating result. The real cost must include the capture plant, electricity and other energy required, pipes, compressors, storage, monitoring, maintenance, financing and the risk of outages.
“If it makes business sense, why can’t the companies pay for it themselves?” The developer’s November 2026 information says the cost of carbon capture is currently higher than the carbon price under the UK Emissions Trading Scheme. It says the scheme needs further construction and operating finance and may need government support. Britain’s wider industrial carbon capture business model allows public revenue support for qualifying projects, including certain capture, transport and storage costs. But Peak Cluster has not been awarded such a contract, so it would be wrong to claim the government has already agreed to pay its full operating bill.
“Has the taxpayer put any money in already?” Yes: the National Wealth Fund announced £28.6 million of public equity investment towards development in July 2025. Equity is an investment that can gain or lose value; it is not the same as a grant. The wider £5 billion investment headline covers Peak Cluster and its associated Morecambe Net Zero proposal together and is not proof of a final itemised and fully financed budget.
“Will I see a Peak Cluster charge on my electricity bill?” No project-specific charge has been established. The potential public cost could instead appear through taxes funding any future subsidy, higher prices for cement and buildings, or particular energy infrastructure costs passed through markets. We must distinguish those possible routes from funding that has actually been approved.
“Before you dig up our countryside, show us the real price, show us who pays it, and show us who carries the risk if the promises fail.”
That is the starting point for Hope to Save Our Countryside‘s formal objection. We are demanding the whole-system cost per tonne permanently stored, an independent account of all public support and guarantees, and a clear explanation of how industrial operators, investors, consumers and taxpayers would share the financial risks.
Hope to Save Our Countryside | 16 November 2026
The route at a glance: from the Peak District to the Irish Sea


The developer has amended parts of the route and the location or size of associated infrastructure since this overview was produced. Do not use this image to determine whether an individual property is affected. Check the current consultation’s interactive map and section booklets here.
Across Derbyshire, Staffordshire, Cheshire and the Wirral, another enormous infrastructure proposal is being presented as the necessary price of Britain’s Net Zero commitments. Its name is Peak Cluster. Its purpose is to capture carbon dioxide from cement and lime works, carry it through a new pipeline network and store it under the East Irish Sea. Behind the reassuring promise of a “resilient future” lies a much more demanding question: has anyone demonstrated that this is the safest, least damaging and best-value way to achieve the claimed benefits?
Our campaign, Hope to Save Our Countryside, is objecting to the current proposals. We recognise that cement and lime are essential British industries, that jobs matter and that industrial process emissions are not eliminated simply by changing fuels. But none of those truths exempts an applicant from proving its engineering, environmental and economic case. A major route across agricultural land is not justified by a slogan, and public financial exposure should never be treated as incidental.
What is actually being proposed?
Peak Cluster brings together industrial producers associated with Tarmac, Breedon, Holcim and SigmaRoc, with the pipeline promoted through Peak Cluster Limited. The offshore transport and storage element, Morecambe Net Zero, is being developed separately by Spirit Energy. The developer says the scheme would capture and store more than three million tonnes of CO₂ per year from four cement and lime plants. That is its projected performance, not an achieved annual result.
According to the November 2026 project information pack, the new onshore pipeline would be approximately 200 kilometres long, up to 36 inches in diameter, generally buried with at least 1.2 metres of cover, and designed for an initial life of 40 years. The developer now proposes transporting CO₂ in gaseous phase at approximately 40 bar gauge. It says the system will not operate in dense phase onshore. Those distinctions are important for assessing hazards honestly: it is wrong to assume every risk characteristic of a high-pressure dense-phase CO₂ pipeline applies unchanged to this design, but equally wrong to assume that gaseous-phase operation eliminates the hazards of a major release.
The project involves much more than a buried pipe. It also includes above-ground installations (AGIs), block valve stations, construction compounds, access tracks, service connections and industrial capture equipment. The developer says its current updated boundary is approximately 100 metres wide in most places, reduced from 300 metres earlier in 2026. But that planning boundary must not be confused with the physical construction working strip. The project information pack anticipates an open-trench working width of up to 40 metres along most of the route, with local variations. Some temporary compounds could be needed for as long as three years.
They changed the route. That is not the same as proving the route is right.
Following over 5,500 pieces of consultation feedback, Peak Cluster says it has revised roughly 15% of the proposed pipeline route. It has also removed the previously proposed Wirral compressor facility and reduced the coastal installation substantially. Credit is due where public objections have caused changes: the revised Wirral concept is materially different. But the need for major redesign demonstrates precisely why early assurances about footprints, landscape impacts and construction requirements should be tested, not simply accepted.
The 12 November announcement confirms that consultation is now focused on the changed boundary, AGIs, valve stations, construction areas and access roads. More detailed consideration of the wider scheme is expected in summer 2027. The present consultation therefore cannot reasonably be treated as the last word on construction, landscape harm, safety or the lifetime cost of the project.
We want the developers to publish a reproducible route-alternatives assessment, with maps identifying affected agricultural land classes, protected habitats, ancient and veteran trees, designated landscapes, watercourses, floodplains, residential areas, schools, roads and rights of way. We also want field-by-field accounting for temporary disturbance, permanent infrastructure and long-term easements. A proposal may return most farmland to agricultural use after reinstatement; that does not erase risks to drainage, soil structure, yields, field access, hedgerows or future land use.
The hidden question: how much power does carbon capture need?
At Hope Cement Works, the question of electricity supply has already attracted criticism from CPRE Peak District and South Yorkshire. The developer’s January 2026 environmental scoping material recognised that the existing power supply was insufficient for carbon capture and considered an extra grid connection, potentially requiring a substation, or on-site power generation with associated gas infrastructure. The precise solution, environmental footprint and consenting strategy were not then settled.
This is not a secondary detail. Capture, purification, compression and transport all require energy. If the solution needs new substations, cables, gas supply or generation, those assets should be identified, assessed and costed as part of the real system required to make the proposal work, with any separate statutory consenting and cumulative effects fully disclosed. The public deserves a transparent energy balance: how much electricity and fuel does the system consume, from where will it come, what does it cost, and what new land and equipment are needed?
The developers themselves acknowledge the finance gap
This is perhaps the most revealing part of the November project information pack. Peak Cluster states that it has raised approximately £60 million to develop the project, but would have to secure further finance to build and operate it, potentially including government support. It also explains that the cost of carbon capture is currently much higher than the UK Emissions Trading Scheme carbon price and that financial support is needed to bridge the gap for producers.
The National Wealth Fund announced £28.6 million of public equity investment in July 2025, as part of a £59.6 million financing round. This was an investment, not a taxpayer grant, and may generate a return. But the distinction does not make risk disappear: it places public capital into a development proposition whose full financing, construction and operating costs are not yet settled. Peak Cluster and Morecambe Net Zero together have been promoted as attracting £5 billion of capital investment. That combined promotional figure is not a published, itemised, independently tested Peak Cluster construction budget.
A further important distinction appeared in Parliament. On 22 May 2026, the Department for Energy Security and Net Zero stated that Peak Cluster was not receiving funding from the department through the CCUS cluster-sequencing process and that, consequently, DESNZ had not prepared a cost-benefit analysis of the project. That answer does not mean no appraisal exists anywhere or that the National Wealth Fund conducted no investment due diligence. It does mean that the departmental appraisal some people may reasonably expect to see was not available at that date. The new November admission of a potential need for government support makes the need for transparent appraisal all the more pressing.
We want a single reconciled whole-system financial account, covering the industrial capture plant, onshore pipeline, additional power and gas connections, offshore transport and geological storage, land acquisition and compensation, construction finance, monitoring, maintenance, major repairs, decommissioning and liability for long-term storage. Show the sources of revenue, who bears capture outages and cost overruns, the proposed allocation of risk between producers, infrastructure owners, investors, energy customers and taxpayers, and what happens if future public support is unavailable.
Pipeline safety cannot be answered by saying that CO₂ is not flammable
Carbon dioxide does not burn. At elevated concentrations, however, it can displace oxygen and create serious exposure hazards. The Health and Safety Executive explains that CO₂ is colourless and odourless and can collect in trenches or low-lying ground after a leak. Because Peak Cluster proposes a specific gaseous-phase, approximately 40-barg design, we expect modelling and emergency arrangements tailored to that design—not careless comparisons with quite different pipelines.
Communities along a long rural alignment should be given comprehensible location-specific information: credible release scenarios, dispersion modelling, distances to homes and public places, low-lying terrain and enclosed spaces, detection and sectional isolation systems, access for emergency services, arrangements for road and footpath closures, evacuation or shelter guidance and response times. This should be informed by HSE and local resilience responders and made available in a form residents can scrutinise before the proposal becomes fixed.
Cheshire East Council formally opposed the proposals in October 2026, citing public safety and environmental concerns and calling for reassessment of routes and impacts. That is not an isolated social-media allegation; it is the published position of a host local authority.

The countryside must not be reduced to a spreadsheet entry
The November information pack describes separate topsoil and subsoil handling, reinstatement and landowner engagement. Those safeguards are welcome as statements of intent, but the test is delivery and enforceability. An open trench across agricultural land, repeated construction movements, temporary drainage diversions and permanent easement restrictions can have consequences far beyond a nominal pipeline footprint.
Every affected holding should have a baseline soil and land-drainage record, an Agricultural Land Classification assessment where relevant, a construction and reinstatement plan, a post-construction monitoring period and a remedy for lost productivity or failed drainage. Hedgerows, mature trees, sensitive habitats, watercourses and historic landscapes require their own route-specific consideration. Permanent valve stations and AGIs require an honest assessment of fencing, lighting, visual effects, access and landscape character. For sensitive places, avoidance must be tested before compensation or habitat-offset claims are used as a substitute.

Nor is the question merely “can a trench be filled in afterwards?” The developer acknowledges that easement rights may restrict buildings and deep-rooted vegetation above the pipe. Landowners and communities deserve to know the consequences for future management, development, planting and access across the proposed 40-year design life and any later extension.
The Planning Inspectorate has already identified evidence gaps
Peak Cluster is a Nationally Significant Infrastructure Project. Its future Development Consent Order will be examined under the Planning Act 2008, with environmental information governed by the Infrastructure Planning (Environmental Impact Assessment) Regulations 2017. The Planning Inspectorate’s February 2026 scoping opinion, case EN0710001, did not grant approval. It required greater certainty over the design, size, location and maximum heights of infrastructure; consideration of environmental effects of AGIs and valve stations across relevant topics, not just landscape; and a justified account of boundary changes and credible worst-case effects.
These are precisely the matters the public is now being asked to assess in a revised boundary consultation. If the route, construction areas and installations are changing, the applicant should publish a clear old-to-new comparison, explain the alternatives rejected and identify where further environmental survey work could change the decision again. We also expect a meaningful assessment of cumulative effects, including enabling electricity and gas infrastructure that may be promoted or consented separately.
We must test performance, not declare success or failure in advance
It would be wrong to claim that carbon capture has never worked anywhere. Industrial CCS projects operate, and cement capture has reached commercial scale at Brevik in Norway. It would be equally wrong to treat a facility somewhere else as proof that this proposal will deliver the claimed three million tonnes every year at its forecast cost. Different feedstocks, capture technologies, utilisation rates, energy supplies, pipeline systems and geological stores have different performance and economic risks.
We therefore demand independent reporting of gross captured CO₂, CO₂ actually delivered to storage, storage availability, capture downtime, operating energy demand, lifecycle emissions and cost per tonne avoided. Performance should be shown under realistic outages and lower-than-expected plant utilisation, not just an optimistic design-day case. The assessment must compare a transparent do-nothing baseline and credible industrial alternatives, as well as the potential loss of British industrial competitiveness under different financing scenarios.
Our position: do not grant this scheme an evidential free pass
Hope to Save Our Countryside is submitting a formal objection to the updated Peak Cluster proposals. Our position is that the present case for the route and associated land take is not adequately justified by the published project information. We require a full alternatives appraisal, robust environmental and public-safety evidence, an integrated assessment of the infrastructure needed to power the scheme, transparent finance and a credible, auditable explanation of net project benefits before any route is locked in.
We are not advocating the closure of British cement works. A country that needs its own industrial foundations cannot casually sacrifice them. But we reject the idea that protecting industry requires communities to accept a poorly explained network of construction corridors and public financial risks. The burden of proof belongs to the promoter, not the farmer, resident or taxpayer who is asked to live with the consequences.
Have your say before 18 December 2026
The present consultation closes on Friday 18 December 2026. The developer’s official feedback form and November 2026 documents and section booklets are available online. You can also email a signed response to consultation@peakcluster.co.uk, identifying your location and the particular route or installation concerns that apply to you. Ask for acknowledgement and retention of the full representation for the consultation report. A further consultation on the wider project is planned for summer 2027: responding now does not prevent you from responding then.
We ask every affected resident, farmer, business, parish council and community group to look beyond the headline promise and examine the footprint, the hazards, the unanswered engineering questions and who will ultimately fund the project.
Primary documents and evidence
- Peak Cluster, Project Information Pack, November 2026 — route, construction method, land rights, finance and project claims.
- Peak Cluster, 12 November 2026 consultation update — revised boundary, Wirral redesign and gaseous-phase specification.
- Planning Inspectorate, Peak Cluster Scoping Opinion, EN0710001, 19 February 2026.
- National Wealth Fund, equity investment announcement, 7 July 2025.
- DESNZ parliamentary answer on cost-benefit analysis, 22 May 2026.
- Cheshire East Council, formal opposition, 16 October 2026.
- CPRE Peak District and South Yorkshire, outstanding power infrastructure questions, 15 October 2026.
- Health and Safety Executive, general hazards of carbon dioxide.
Hope to Save Our Countryside Campaign | Evidence reviewed 15 November 2026. We distinguish the developer’s projected claims from achieved performance and reserve our position on subsequent designs and disclosures.

Leave a Reply